Notice: the WebSM website has not been updated since the beginning of 2018.

Web Survey Bibliography

Title Matrix vs. Single Question Formats in Web Surveys: Results from a large scale experiment
Author Klausch, L. T., de Leeuw, E. D., Hox, J., de Jongh, A., Roberts , A.
Year 2012
Access date 30.04.2012
Abstract

Relevance & Research Question: A matrix question format (grid) has may advantages in traditional paper-and-pen surveys design: more questions can be presented in a smaller space, thereby saving paper, printing and mailing costs. With the onset of computer-assisted questionnaires and Internet research, these cost saving arguments are no longer valid. Still, matrix questions remain a widely used tool also in Web surveys (e.g. Couper, 2008). There is some empirical evidence (e.g. Toepoel et al 2005; Petchev, 2006; Callegaro, 2010) that matrix questions lead to more statisficing and more dropout. However, presenting questions as single items on the screen leads to longer response times and may increase response burden. In this study we therefore evaluate an alternative to traditional matrix and scrolling formats for web surveys: the horizontal scrolling matrix (HSM).
Methods & Data: In the HSM questions are presented one-by-one on the screen, while ease of answering is improved (e.g., after an answer is selected, the next question is quickly and automatically presented, there is no need for the next or previous button, etc.), and respondents still have an overview of the number of questions in the matrix through a visual bar. In a randomized field experiment we tested whether the HSM question format does improve data quality over the traditional matrix format. We used a 2 by 3 factorial design: the experimental factors were (1) question format: traditional matrix vs HSM and (2) length of ‘matrix’: 5, 10, and 15 items per matrix.
Results: The results were positive: the HSM-format led to fewer break-offs, better data quality and less satisficing as indicated by well-known response styles, such as non-differentiation and extremeness. The HSM helped improving data quality in the longer matrix conditions, which typically suffer from worse data quality. Finally, respondents evaluated the HSM format very positive.
Added Value: Online researchers can profit from the flexibility of web surveys by moving away from grid formats, which are a heritage of paper and pencil surveys. The HSM is a useful alternative, which prevents respondent demotivation by offering superior usability.

Access/Direct link

GOR Homepage (abstract) / (full text)

Year of publication2012
Bibliographic typeConferences, workshops, tutorials, presentations
Full text availabilityFurther details
Print

Web survey bibliography - General Online Research Conference (GOR) 2012 (40)